How to Evaluate an Orthopedic Billing Company Using Five Real Claim Scenarios

Orthopedic Billing Company Guide | 5 Claim Scenarios
Orthopedic Billing5 min read

Key takeaways

  • Give each orthopedic billing company the same five claim scenarios and ask it to show the work.
  • Score the evidence you see, from authorization checks through payment reconciliation.
  • Put ownership, deadlines, and reporting expectations in writing before you sign.

Your orthopedic billing company says a surgery claim was paid. Your administrator pulls the remittance and sees an allowed amount below what the contract appears to call for. Who checks the difference, decides whether it’s collectible, and follows up with the payer?

To evaluate an orthopedic billing company, give each vendor the same five claim scenarios. Ask them to show the record they would check, who would own the next step, and how your practice would know the work was done. Use these illustrative scenarios as written or swap in your own de-identified examples.

01 Prior authorization stopped matching the surgery

A knee surgery moves to a different facility after authorization. The scheduler updates the calendar, but the team still has the original approval on file.

Ask the billing company. Show us who compares the final facility, procedure, side, and date against the approval, and what happens if a change needs payer review.

Evidence to look for. A work queue with an owner, a payer reference, and a documented decision before the case proceeds or the claim is released. Link the workflow to your practice’s escalation process.

02 A post-op visit may be part of the global package

A patient returns for routine follow-up and also reports a new issue. The charge enters the billing queue while the patient is still in the surgical global period.

Ask the billing company. Walk us through how you determine what belongs to the surgical package and what might be separately reportable under the applicable payer rules. What documentation would you need?

Evidence to look for. A coder checks the procedure, date, and note before releasing the charge. Ask why the team made its decision and where it recorded that rationale.

See how Medicare treats services in the global package and separately reportable care in the CMS Global Surgery booklet. Check the applicable plan’s policy for the claim you review.

03 A graft claim denies for missing documentation

An orthopedic graft line denies and the remittance points to missing documentation. The office has the operative report, but nobody can show which records the payer received.

Ask the billing company. Show us how you decide whether the next action is a claim correction, document submission, or appeal. Who gets the operative report, and who owns the deadline?

Evidence to look for. A work item with the denial reason, payer instructions, required records, deadline, submission proof, and follow-up date. Ask how the team alerts the practice when the same denial repeats.

04 A claim shows as submitted but the payer can’t find it

The EHR lists a fracture-care claim as submitted. The payer portal returns no matching claim and there’s no remittance.

Ask the billing company. Show us how you trace the claim from the practice system through the clearinghouse and into the payer’s records. At what point would you correct and resubmit it?

Evidence to look for. The vendor can show available acknowledgments, identify where the record stops, preserve filing evidence, and explain how it avoids submitting a duplicate while investigating.

For Medicare claim-status options, see the CMS guide to checking claim status.

05 A paid claim may be underpaid

A surgery claim is marked paid, but the allowed amount on one line looks low compared with the applicable fee schedule.

Ask the billing company. Reconcile the allowed amount against our agreement. Show how you check the plan, effective rate, units, and applicable payment adjustments before flagging an underpayment.

Evidence to look for. A line-level calculation showing the expected and actual allowed amounts, the reason for any difference, and the owner and deadline for pursuing a confirmed shortfall.

06 How to Score an Orthopedic Billing Company

Score each scenario from 0 to 2, for a total of 10 points. Ask each team for the same evidence. If they use sample reports in the demo, confirm what your practice will be able to see after onboarding.

ScoreWhat the vendor shows
0A general answer with no example or clear owner.
1A plausible workflow, with gaps in ownership, timing, or documentation.
2A clear workflow and a de-identified example showing what was checked, who owns the next action, and how it’s tracked to resolution.

Review the weakest scenario alongside the total. If orthopedic surgery billing is losing revenue after payment, for example, a vendor that scores well on submission but can’t show a contract-rate review still leaves you with work to assign. When comparing orthopedic billing services, put authorization ownership, coding review, appeals, aged A/R, and underpayment follow-up in the scope of work. Ask which items carry separate fees and who will handle claims already in progress at handoff.

The Bottom Line

Use the same five scenarios to evaluate a prospective vendor or your current team. Start with the claim that took the most time to resolve and ask what the team would change before the next one comes in. Explore AHR’s medical billing services.

Topics:Orthopedic BillingPrior AuthorizationDenial ManagementUnderpayments
Next
Next

Radiofrequency Ablation CPT Code Guide for Pain Practices